Netflix’s Bridgerton has confirmed a major shift for its upcoming fifth season, placing Francesca Bridgerton, played by actress Hannah Dodd, at the center of the story—alongside a gender-swapped love interest, Michaela Stirling, played by Masali Baduza.
While the announcement has generated excitement, particularly following a teaser captioned, “Do not fret, dearest readers, for a certain countess shall find love again,” it has also sparked debate among fans over the show’s evolving timeline and departures from Julia Quinn’s original novels.
The new season will follow Francesca after the death of her husband, John Stirling, as her relationship with his cousin, Michaela, develops into the show’s first central queer romance.
“It feels groundbreaking,” showrunner Jess Brownell told Tudum. “But to make an entire ‘Bridgerton’ season about a sapphic relationship feels huge.”
The shift builds on narrative changes already introduced in earlier seasons. In Quinn’s book When He Was Wicked, Francesca ultimately finds love with Michael Stirling, John’s cousin.
However, the series has reimagined that character as Michaela, setting up a different dynamic.
“Netflix had already taken liberties in adapting Quinn’s books throughout the first few seasons, so we probably should’ve seen an exciting new twist to Francesca’s story coming,” notes a review from the blog What is Quinn Reading.
The creative decision has divided viewers, with some questioning the pacing and order of storylines.
In the book series, Francesca’s story is preceded by her older sister Eloise’s, though, as of season four of the Netflix series, Eloise, played by Claudia Jessie, is still slowly warming to the idea of entering the marriage mart.
On Reddit, where fans gathered to react to the announcement, one disgruntled fan wrote, “If they wanted to push Eloise back, they shouldn’t have brought Colin forward,” referencing the third alphabetically-named Bridgerton sibling.
“It’s bizarre since the whole reason Eloise rethinks marriage is [Penelope], and Colin gets engaged to Pen during Francesca’s story canonically, so if anything [Penelope and Colin’s story] could have been pushed back even further to develop the friends-to-lovers storyline more fully.”
Others have taken a more measured view, suggesting the change allows for better narrative buildup with Eloise’s love interest, Phillip Crane.
“I think Phillip will probably be in this season, perhaps there’ll be a subplot where they start writing to each other,” one Reddit user commented, alluding to the plot of Quinn’s novel, To Sir Phillip, With Love.
“I love Eloise, but I think they made the right choice…it would be weird to dive right into Philoise with no buildup.”
Still, concerns about timing remain a recurring theme. “Even if there’s a time jump in the storyline, starting Francesca’s season three episodes after John’s funeral will feel too soon to a lot of viewers,” another viewer wrote.
Some fans have also speculated that production decisions may be influenced by cast popularity, with one Reddit user joking, “Shondaland loves Claudia Jessie so much they’re delaying her season for as long as possible.”
The upcoming season will also include a reported two-year time jump, allowing Francesca time to grieve the death of her husband in season four before re-entering society, according to Tudum.
Netflix has yet to confirm a release date for Bridgerton season 5, but as production gets underway, the reaction underscores a balancing act between honoring the source material and expanding the series’ scope, while staying true to the series that fans have long loved.
Newsweek has reached out to Netflix for comment via email.
Read the full article here
