Recently, PwC highlighted key insights in “President Trump’s Agenda: What to Expect Next.” Under the Tax Policy section, they emphasize modeling various scenarios of potential tax proposals. In today’s climate of uncertainty—locally, nationally, and globally—the role of estate planners as risk managers is more crucial than ever. With the political and economic landscape shifting, including the potential sunset of the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA), looming recession threats, and the possibility of increased tariffs, clients are faced with unprecedented uncertainties. While traditional estate planning often focuses on short-term tax benefits, adopting a long-term, scenario-based approach is now essential.
The Estate Planner as a Strategic Risk Manager
Risk management in estate planning has progressed beyond merely safeguarding assets from taxes and liabilities. According to the International Organization for Standardization (ISO 31000), risk management involves addressing both negative and positive impacts of uncertainty on objectives. This evolution calls for estate planners to adopt a broader, strategic approach, focusing on mitigating risks while seizing opportunities.
Estate planning strategies typically include:
- Transferring Risk (e.g., life insurance, annuities, asset protection structures)
- Avoiding Risk (e.g., charitable remainder trusts, dynasty trusts)
- Reducing Risk (e.g., discounting techniques, irrevocable trusts, gifting strategies)
- Accepting Risk (e.g., maintaining illiquid assets in an estate under IRC §6166 to defer estate taxes)
Emerging Risks and Uncertainties
The Sunset of the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA)
The 2017 TCJA notably increased the estate and gift tax exemption. It is set to revert to approximately $6-7 million per individual in 2026 unless Congress intervenes. This potential change could create significant estate tax liabilities for high-net-worth (HNW) and ultra-high-net-worth (UHNW) individuals who do not leverage the current higher exemption levels.
Risk Management Strategies:
- Utilize the current exemption by making substantial lifetime gifts before the sunset.
- Establish grantor-retained annuity trusts (GRATs) and spousal lifetime access trusts (SLATs) to secure tax benefits.
- Consider dynasty trusts for multi-generational tax efficiency.
Potential Economic Recession
Market volatility and economic slowdowns can severely affect wealth preservation and transfer strategies. Declining asset values can influence valuations for estate and gift tax planning.
Risk Management Strategies:
- Engage in valuation discounting techniques when asset prices are lower.
- Structure estate plans with flexible provisions, such as powers of appointment and disclaimer trusts.
- Maintain liquidity in trusts and estates to withstand economic downturns.
Rising Tariffs and Global Trade Uncertainty
Higher tariffs and supply chain disruptions could affect business valuations and investment portfolios. Families with international business interests face additional complexities in estate planning.
Risk Management Strategies:
- Diversify investments to hedge against geopolitical risks.
- Consider using foreign trusts or offshore asset protection structures to mitigate tax and trade risks.
- Implement succession planning for global family-owned businesses that may be affected by trade policy shifts.
Scenario Planning as a Framework for Estate Planning
To effectively navigate these uncertainties, estate planners should integrate scenario planning into their strategies. A useful framework is the TAIDA (Tracking, Analysis, Imaging, Decision and Action) model:
- Tracking: Monitor tax policy developments, economic indicators, and regulatory changes. Stay informed about proposed legislation and court rulings that could impact estate planning.
- Analysis: Evaluate the potential consequences of various scenarios, such as tax law changes or a market downturn. Collaborate with financial advisors to model different financial outcomes.
- Imaging: Develop a vision for the future, considering both worst-case and best-case scenarios. Engage clients in discussions about their long-term objectives and the potential risks to their wealth.
- Deciding: Identify strategies that align with the client’s risk tolerance and objectives. Use flexible estate planning techniques to allow for adjustments as circumstances evolve.
- Acting: Implement estate planning strategies proactively, while maintaining the ability to adapt as new risks emerge. Continuously review and revise plans in response to changing conditions.
Hypothetical Examples of Scenario Planning in Estate Planning
Example 1: Navigating the TCJA Sunset
A business owner with a $20 million estate is uncertain about making large lifetime gifts before the TCJA exemption expires. By modeling different scenarios—one where the exemption reverts and one where it remains—the estate planner helps the client understand the tax consequences of each outcome. Consequently, the client decides to gift $10 million into a trust for heirs, ensuring tax-efficient wealth transfer regardless of legislative changes.
Example 2: Preparing for a Market Downturn
A client with significant stock holdings is concerned about a potential recession. Through scenario planning, the estate planner models the impact of a market downturn on the estate’s value. The client then implements a strategy to transfer assets while valuations are lower, reducing estate tax exposure and maximizing the benefits of valuation discounts.
Example 3: Managing International Business Risks
A family business with global operations faces uncertainty due to potential tariffs and trade restrictions. The estate planner models different economic scenarios and advises the client to restructure ownership using an international trust. This ensures that the business can adapt to policy changes while securing long-term asset protection and succession planning.
Conclusion
In an era marked by political and economic uncertainty, estate planners must serve as strategic risk managers. The sunset of the TCJA, economic volatility, and global trade disruptions necessitate proactive, scenario-based estate planning. By incorporating scenario planning into their practice, estate planners can help clients mitigate risks, maximize opportunities, and achieve long-term financial security.
Read the full article here
