The new Hulu dating series Are You My First? has been dubbed “Love Island for virgins,” featuring virgin Mormons, virgin FBoys and even a virgin OnlyFans creator. And in case you missed the fact that the cast is made up of all virgins, hosts and narrators Colton Underwood and Kaitlyn Bristowe are there to remind you with endless puns about popped cherries in voiceovers and games throughout the 10-episode season. “We probably made one too many,” Kaitlyn, 40, tells Us Weekly about the virgin puns. Colton, 33, disagrees. “I’m a more is more type of guy,” he says in the…