Drafted No. 4 overall in 2023 by the Indianapolis Colts, Anthony Richardson entered the NFL as one of the most physically gifted quarterback prospects in recent memory.
At 6-foot-4, 244 pounds, with elite rushing ability and a rocket arm, he was billed as a franchise-altering dual-threat, and the early flashes were promising.
In his first four NFL starts, he completed 59.5% of his passes for 577 yards with three TDs to just one INT, plus 136 rushing yards and four rushing touchdowns, averaging 5.4 yards per carry.
That blend of explosiveness and dual-threat production is why teams saw superstar upside, when he was actually on the field.
The issue is that Richardson has completed just over 50% of his passes, thrown more interceptions than touchdowns, and, most critically, has barely stayed on the field, appearing in just 17 games in three years.
Now, the Colts have made an official decision on his future with the franchise.
On Friday, May 1, Indianapolis declined Richardson’s fifth-year option, a decision that would have guaranteed him roughly $22.5 million in 2027.
More news: Latest Patrick Mahomes Update Should Have the Entire NFL Terrified
Fifth-year options are a franchise’s way of signaling belief in their former first-round pick. Teams often exercise them even for flawed players, if only to maintain cost-controlled leverage. Declining it, though, indicates the team had reached a breaking point where they believed the risk outweighs the upside.
Committing $22.5 million to a quarterback who has struggled with durability, accuracy, and consistency is a gamble, and one Indianapolis apparently no longer wants to make.
Financially, the Colts gain flexibility. They avoid a guaranteed future cap hit and can redirect resources toward stabilizing the roster, whether that’s reinforcing the offensive line, adding weapons, or doubling down on a different quarterback in the future.
Strategically, it aligns with everything they’ve already done. The team handed the offense to Jones, explored veteran stopgaps, and even entertained trade conversations involving Richardson.
In other words, this decision simply makes official the direction they’ve been heading for months.
More news: Kirby Smart Lands Next Brock Bowers as No. 2 TE Jaxon Dollar Commits to Georgia
More news: George Pickens Makes a Statement Right After Signing Cowboys Franchise Tag
As for Richardson, there are a few realistic paths on the table.
The first (and most likely) option would be for him to get traded. Richardson has already requested a trade and skipped offseason activities. Teams without a long-term answer at QB (like the New York Jets, Cleveland Browns, Pittsburgh Steelers, Minnesota Vikings, and Arizona Cardinals, for example) that still value his potential could see Richardson as a rebuildable asset.
Alternatively, if no deal materializes, he could stay in Indianapolis as a backup option in 2026, essentially playing for his next contract in what would be a prove-it season.
And if nothing else, without the option, Richardson will hit the open market young enough to reset his career in the right system.
Kevin O’Connell (Vikings) and Sean McVay (Los Angeles Rams) are two coaches who have built strong reputations for getting the most out of young (often overlooked) quarterbacks.
Both franchises also have not fully committed to anyone as their long-term answer at the position.
Richardson still has the traits. The question now is whether he’ll finally get the time (and the right environment) to turn them into something real.
Read the full article here
